Good Design, Now What?

Written by , Published On 11th March 2009.
Filed in Business.

Here at Design Shack, we’ve built up a solid archive of the best designs the web has to offer. When browsing through the 3,000+ sites featured, it’s hard to fully grasp the amount of time and effort put into the design and development of each one.

That’s why it breaks my heart when I see a brilliant site screenshot taken the day it was launched, but when clicking to visit the live version, I find a shell of what it used to be.

It’s not our fault.

crumpled_paperjpg
The site we delivered didn’t have that cluttered home page, confusing expanded navigation bar, or that insanely huge logo. All that work done in carefully considering user experience and overall design aesthetic has been picked apart by a committee with as many different web agendas as members. Why on earth would someone pay good money for solid design and development, only to turnaround and dismantle what has been put in place in a few short months.

Actually, maybe it is.

It is hard to be committed to educating clients. Things rarely sink in the first time, you want to make them happy, and you have to make good use of the time for which they are paying you. While there are occasions when you’ll simply be out voted, out numbered or straight up out of time, there are a few things you can do.

Set the right tone.

605479_thumbs_down_with_clipping_pathjpg
Do you want to be hired as the micromanaged grunt worker or the trusted expert with the skill set clients need? It’s easy to get into saying yes to whatever clients think they need at the beginning in order to give a good first impression or sell your services. They may like you as a yes man or woman, but I promise you they won’t respect you. It’s usually not because they are jerks, it’s because you haven’t earned it. Don’t be afraid to assert your opinions and establish a good working relationship. They’ll learn to trust you, and if you take the time to explain why and educate them about what websites need to be, you just might be looking at a long term business relationship where you are consulting and managing aspects of the site yourself.

Tell the truth, immediately.

Put your time into design and code, and try to avoid spending your time writing an overly-gentle email fielding suggestions or trying to incorporate bad ideas into your layout. While being nice and compromising are part of the collective creative process, it’s always good to be as efficient and to-the-point as you can.

When choosing or building a CMS, limitations are great.

I am pleased to say that we’ve always drawn a hard line on this. Half of the time we are hired for redesigns, it is because the staff or web administrator has too much access. Hot pink comic sans text and a quadrupled number of pages added to the site map happen all too often. As designers, we are branding their online content and architecting a user experience. Don’t give them the keys to the castle. I find it is fairly easy to convince clients of this when you talk about saving money regarding the increased longevity of their new site design. No one wants to have to pay for a redesign every year.

Be aware that sites can degrade quickly.

I opened up a psd version of a site I was involved in building last year and gave myself 5 minutes to degrade it. Check out the original here and the degraded version here. After carrying out a handful of common mistakes I’ve seen in site management, I was honestly horrified at how easy it was to ruin the layout. If you see a site even partially take a turn for the worse, speak up!

Good Luck.

To quote a friend of mine who is a farmer, “The only thing that is certain is hardship.” Clients will always be tough to deal with, but if you put time and effort into building an honest & communicative relationship, there is a good chance it will pay off in the long run.

Discussion

  1. Daniel says:

    Great article, it really explains what kind of abuse our designs are facing everyday!

  2. shae says:

    Excellent post, i appreciate the example (before/after) site.. I’ve seen that happen WAY to many times with my designs.

  3. Charles M. says:

    Great article – really touched home. I recently had a client walk on me from do this do that perspective – not cool. That and it is tough to combat the client’s ideas of what they think looks good when it doesn’t – and this gives us a baseline to work from to get through that. Thank you for great content.

  4. WYSIWYG and modules like TinyMCE can ruin a site if not administered correctly.

    I prefer to use an article based CMS and give them publishing options that won’t break my carefully considered site design!

  5. Trent says:

    @steven Hambleton: couldn’t agree more. Now if we could keep clients from typing 3+ line article titles!

  6. bharat negi says:

    Excellent post, i appreciate the example (before/after) site.. I’ve seen that happen WAY to many times with my designs.

  7. tomcanji says:

    Great post. Makes me realize some of the mistakes I make on daily basis

  8. Zia says:

    That saved me from making further mistakes.. Thanks alot.

  9. jimram says:

    “Tell the truth, immediately” – This is so important, its an approach we’ve recently adopted at our studio and clients seem to appreciate being challenged with a different opinion.

    If you dont stand up for your corner and take control then you’ll only end up getting frustrated when you start pixel pushing

  10. John Weis says:

    that was really encouraging…

  11. Pete says:

    a site should not teach a user – in my opinion, a fast and easy navigation is the most important part of a good website – of course the content should fit the this navigation…

  12. drew says:

    Pictures on the web are all the same resolution. Do you mean it’s been scaled up? Also, the before picture looks disturbingly like a burning cross.

  13. There is a vital skill required by all designers, the art of selling via a logical rational that makes senese and adds confidence to the client, scene setting that builds expectation and understanding and then theres honesty… it will always show.

  14. Vakuumierer says:

    Excellent post, thanks a lot.

Leave Your Reply